Comments on: UPDATED: In Defense Of Hans-Hermann Hoppe https://barelyablog.com/in-defense-of-hans-hermann-hoppe/ by ilana mercer Wed, 02 Apr 2025 19:29:09 +0000 hourly 1 By: Myron Pauli https://barelyablog.com/in-defense-of-hans-hermann-hoppe/comment-page-1/#comment-11015 Mon, 28 Jun 2010 15:35:33 +0000 http://barelyablog.com/?p=26824#comment-11015 I don’t feel qualified to get into 14 + year intellectual jousts between paleolibertarians, paleoconservatives, anarcho-libertarians, and classical liberals. I will say this about immigration:

Our current de facto situation between the 50 states, federal government, and Mexico is nothing resembling any sort of libertarian ideal. Everything has been distorted by: (1) War on Drugs, (2) Labor laws (minimum wages, etc.),
(3) Welfare state benefits, and (4) Spottily enforced immigration laws. The result is 1-1.5 million new people coming each year into the USA, mostly illegal, and not per se culturally consistent with the rest of the nation. Also, there are 10 – 20 million people in some legal purgatory collecting some benefits and working while also available for exploitation by criminal mafias and unscrupulous employers (seeking a competitive edge with “illegal” labor).

My suggestion is to first plug the leak with a SECURE BORDER. Secondly, reduce or eliminate the war on Drugs. Third, eliminate “benefits” for trespassers (and everyone else eventually). AFTER that, reducing labor restrictions, selective earned amnesties (for otherwise law abiding productive workers), etc. could be discussed in a hopefully libertarian context. No doubt, it will be a very acrimonious debate!

]]>
By: james huggins https://barelyablog.com/in-defense-of-hans-hermann-hoppe/comment-page-1/#comment-11014 Mon, 28 Jun 2010 12:48:34 +0000 http://barelyablog.com/?p=26824#comment-11014 I don’t know Herr Hoppe nor do I know anything about him. But I do know and understand national socialism and have always detested those who quickly shout “Nazi” at anybody who doesn’ fit their particular view. The same goes for “racist”, “fascist”, “communist”, “homophobe” etc. Most accusers haven’t the slightest idea what goes to make up the group they which they happily accuse others of belonging. What a crock.

]]>
By: robert https://barelyablog.com/in-defense-of-hans-hermann-hoppe/comment-page-1/#comment-11010 Sun, 27 Jun 2010 21:38:35 +0000 http://barelyablog.com/?p=26824#comment-11010 Ilana,
I appreciate your insight into this because I do not know Mr. Hoppe as you do. I do think I know you somewhat and your treatment of friends and acquaintances is something to be admired.
I think I may have sent this to you from the discussion about Piatak’s article but I do appreciate your honesty and respect for those you know.

“Yes, but Ilana Mercer describes herself as a paloe-libertarian yet her natural instincts are toward self sacrifice and civility. She is not haughty and does not look for opportune times to sabotage her friends and acquaintances. I really believe this is all a matter of class more than ideology or as the Aristotelians would have it:
“a matter of a manners related to morals.” We must not turn this into a diatribe against thoughtful libertarians. I prefer it as an attack against low class scoundrels with poor demeanor and morals. I would defend Ilana Mercer to say whatever she pleases because she is honest in allowing others to respond and has respect for the truth of things. It is different for those fearful of poverty and willing to say or do anything for a buck –even the sacrifice of friends and fools alike.”

]]>