Your government—Democrat and Republican—is in the process of mass murdering and obliterating other nations (peoples) and their physical habitat and environment. We’ve killed a nation and a strip of land in Gaza. We’re in the process of aiding that same outcome in the West Bank and East Jerusalem: We’re helping mad dog Israel bulldoze the homes in those territories–the schools and hospitals–and evict and murder those areas’ Palestinian inhabitants. Yemen, impoverished, is in America-Isra sights for destruction, too. Iran, perhaps.

With such criminal culpability—your question about the validity of the closed-border immigration perspective in the USA is excellent. I salute you for thinking.